Selling Freshly to Nestle for $1.5B and Keeping $100M 

November 13, 2026 |  

About this episode

Subscribe:

Every founder faces a choice at some point: own all of a business you can finance yourself, or give up most of it to raise the capital for something much bigger. Mike Wystrach chose the second path. He co-founded Freshly in 2012, raised more than $100 million in venture capital and another $50 million in venture debt, and by the time Nestle acquired the company for $1.5 billion in 2020 he owned just under 10 percent. He walked away with roughly $100 million. 

Mike learned the mechanics of a venture term sheet while he was negotiating one, and in this episode he breaks down the terms that sit behind a headline valuation and decide what a founder actually keeps if they take outside money. In this episode of Built to Sell Radio, you discover how to: 

  • Decide whether to keep 100 percent of a business you can self-fund or trade ownership for a shot at a much bigger outcome 
  • Understand why an investor will happily give you any valuation you want as long as they get a 3x liquidation preference 
  • Tell the difference between a pari passu preference stack and last-in-first-out, and why it determines who gets paid when a sale comes in below the money raised 
  • Read past the valuation to the blocking rights and preferred rights that let a minority investor veto a sale 
  • Negotiate a right of offer instead of a right of first refusal so a strategic investor can’t box out other bidders when it’s time to sell 
  • Take money off the table through a secondary sale, and why your first million is worth more than your last twenty 
  • Recognize the moment you stop being an owner and become a CEO with a fiduciary duty to every shareholder 

Show Notes & Links

Connect with Mike on LinkedIn

Visit Mike’s website

 

Learn more about today’s sponsor, TAB.

 

 

 

 

Learn more about today’s sponsor Axial.

Axial logo

 

Definitions

 

Due-Diligence: This is a comprehensive appraisal of a business or investment undertaken before a merger, acquisition, or investment. It seeks to validate the information provided and uncover any potential risks or liabilities.

Earn-out: This is a financing arrangement for the purchase of a business, where the seller must meet certain performance goals before receiving the full purchase price. It reduces the buyer’s risk and aligns the interests of both parties post-acquisition.

Errors and Omissions Insurance (E&O): This is a form of liability insurance that protects companies and their employees against claims of inadequate or negligent actions, particularly in professional advice and services.

Re-Trading: This occurs when a buyer attempts to renegotiate the purchase price of a deal after initially agreeing to one. It is often seen unfavorably as it occurs after due diligence, seemingly exploiting newly discovered information.

About Our Guest

Mike Wystrach

Mike Wystrach is the co-founder of Freshly, the prepared-meal delivery company he started in 2012 with $15 in the bank. He grew up on a ranch in southern Arizona, and before Freshly he worked in equity sales on Wall Street and opened a restaurant that failed. He says that failure taught him more about business than anything else. He grew Freshly to about 2,500 employees shipping more than a million meals a week across 48 states. In 2020 he sold it to Nestlé for $1.5 billion.

Today Mike is co-founder and co-CEO of Petfolk, a chain of veterinary care centers he runs with his sister, Dr. Audrey Wystrach. He is also co-founder of Cutting Horse, a firm that invests in consumer brands. He hosts The Advantage, a weekly podcast and newsletter for consumer-brand founders. He lives in New York.

© All Rights Reserved | Built To Sell