Mike Wystrach started Freshly in 2012 with $15 in the bank and his mother’s ranch on the line. Eight years later, Nestle bought the meal delivery company for $1.5 billion.
By then Mike owned just under 10 percent. Freshly had raised more than $100 million in venture capital and another $50 million in venture debt along the way, and every round shaved down his stake. He still walked away with roughly $100 million, because he traded most of a small company for a piece of a much bigger one.
He joins John Warrillow on the latest episode of Built to Sell Radio to break down the venture terms that decide what a founder actually keeps. Listen and you’ll learn how to:
- Decide whether to own all of a business you can fund yourself or a slice of something much bigger
- Spot why an investor will give you any valuation you want as long as they get a 3x liquidation preference
- Tell a pari passu preference stack from last-in-first-out, and why it matters when a sale comes in below the money raised
- Find the blocking rights that let a minority investor veto your sale
- Negotiate a right of offer instead of a right of first refusal so a strategic investor can’t box out other bidders
- Take money off the table through a secondary sale
- Recognize the moment you stop being an owner and become a CEO with a duty to every shareholder
Mike also explains why every secondary sale he made was, on paper, a huge mistake. The first $1 million he took off the table would have been worth $20 million if he’d held on. He doesn’t regret it for a second.
Watch the full episode below.
Quote of the Week
Your first million is worth way more than your last 20 million.
Mike Wystrach on why he never regretted taking money off the table early.
Deals
- Kel-Gor, an Ontario-based industrial contractor with nearly 60 years of history providing maintenance, turnaround, and fabrication services to petrochemical and refining facilities, was acquired by Bird Construction (TSX: BDT), a leading Canadian specialty contractor, for $200M (CAD). Kel-Gor is expected to generate over $250M in revenue in 2027, implying a valuation of less than 1x forward revenue.

